Udaan Review – It speaks from the heart and goes right through it says Fatema Kagalwala

Posted: May 22, 2010 by moifightclub in bollywood, cast & crew, cinema, film, Film Festival, film review
Tags: , , , , ,

Some of us were lucky enough to catch a screening of Vikramaditya Motwane’s Udaan. I came back, sat down with my laptop on the writing table, wrote the header for my post – Days Of Being Wild & the Pains of Growing Up. Looked up. The poster of Persepolis, newly framed, was in front of me. I put on the same thinking pose and in my thought bubble went back to the days of that small industrial town where I grew up. Same state, different town. Udaan is  set in Jamshedpur.

The post remains unwritten and is saved as a draft with only the header . Cinema that connects  strongly, has this effect on me. Either I go silent or feel like pouring my heart out. After Vihir, Udaan is the second film of 2010 that I fell in love with. And the best part is, its uncompromised. Who would cast Ronit Roy, Ram Kapoor and  a bunch of new kids to make a film! Producer Anurag Kashyap and Sanjay Singh did. And Vikramaditya delivered. More power to people who dare to make such films! A script which was rejected by almost every producer in Bollylalaland, got made, and made it to Cannes’ official selection. Aur bolo?!

Finally, good friend Fatema Kagalwala came to our rescue. Yes, same Fatema, the girl on the bike (She doesn’t like the description but we feel it sounds cool like the title The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo)! And she drives smoothly even after four pegs! Anyway, back to Udaan. Read on.

There is moment of breaking-free in every teenager’s life. From barriers within or without. And this is a journey that defines the rest of life’s journey. The moment when one takes wing. And flies away to find one’s feet in a world where the present is free from the past and the future a freedom to dream and build.

It is said that the things that we cannot change, in this flux of constantly changing life, are the things that end up changing us the most. But it is also the things we break ourselves to change that end up keeping us together. Rohan finds that out as he sets out to find himself among the pieces of life thrown to him by fate. Thrown out of hostel and college for a breach of (archaic) rules he finds himself in his home with an over-bearing, uncaring, violent father and a step-brother he has no knowledge of. The odds are stacked against him and larger because of his nature.

Rohan is a poet, a sensitive soul…fully well personifed in Rajat Barmecha’s soulful eyes and tender expression. And the poetry he writes is equally touching. He writes of his innermost quests, his need to find his path, his feet in a confusing world of do’s and don’ts that don’t make sense to his simple desires and simple individuality.

Rohan’s dilemma is as special as it is common. A semi-neurotic father with demons of his own to battle clamping down hard on the gentle boy and his harmless dreams forms the core of his life that is now reduced to an empty carton much like the cold, spaceless walls that adorn his house. The only sense of belonging he ever felt is far away in Mumbai, the city of dreams, his bunch of pot-pourri friends that are seemingly very happy and carefree, a life Rohan craves for. A shadow of a loving yet unattainable family in his chachu’s person and marriage gives Rohan the much needed respite from the tyranny and cruelty of his circumstances…

But Udaan needs to be experienced not explained. It’s a simple story, simply told. And like a friend said, a ‘difficult’ simple film to make. As it goes in simple stories what you don’t do is more important than what you do. It is the pitfalls that are avoided that make the subtle milestones achievements. Writers Vikramaditya Motwane and Anurag Kashyap pick and choose moments, shear them of over-emphasis, indulgence and sentimentality and present a coming-of-age story that is as universal as unique.

Of course, there are also moments of glorification that seem out of place…a bit of clichéd representation of conventional thinking…a bit of over-doing of the ‘feel-good’ factor…they make for a few wincing moments…taking away from the absorbing true-ness of the film…somewhere indicating a lack of real depth…but they do not take away from the soul of the film, which is clean and sincere, much like it’s protagonist and his dreams.

The film is Rohan’s story but the other characters complete his picture well. The balance in characterization, a rare treat, is a genuine pleasure to experience, especially the father’s. A brutish tyrant who could have been painted black and explained away, is handled with a touch of grey never justifying his behaviour but by just putting a germ of reason as to why he must have turned out like this. A back story would have killed it. Especially with the diversity of perspective that is brought in by how Rohan looks at him, how his brother looks at him and how the audience looks at him. It clearly makes us take sides but with an understanding. And that understanding is fraught with the knowledge that life is like that. Imperfect and full of tough choices. And it takes the theme (as it may be defined) that either you let your past dictate your present or you dissociate and build a new present for yourself. Beautiful contrasting life choices in the personification of the father-son.

The step-brother (a perfect cute-heart casting) brings out more of this of balancing out of the human-ness of its characters. His fears are matched well with his simple dignity and his silence used perfectly to show his place and role in the scheme of things. His small and limited presence looms large, very telling of the family dynamics and Rohan’s decisions.

Generically, the film is very European in its film-making sensibilities. The use of sound and silence is stark, contrasting. The cinematography captures without drawing attention to itself (the denial of over-weening cine-artistry is actually a pleasure in these times of technology obsessed film-making). The dialogues are conversational, everyday life but never pedestrian. The power of realism rests in every creative choice the director makes to tell his story in the most earthy fashion. And the power of realism shines through a well-told story that speaks from the heart and goes right through the heart. An extremely heart-warming debut by director Vikramaditya Motwane, one that shoots our expectations of his second feature sky-high 🙂

  1. raulkumar says:

    I am so psyched to read this……… Now i am even more excited to watch the movie

  2. moifightclub says:

    And no mention of my fav Ram Kapoor! two scenes and he steals the show. he deserves much more. someone please give him something better than all those saansbahu shit!

  3. Fatema says:

    Well…I thought he was like ok types, good but could have been better. Sorry! 🙂

  4. raulkumar says:

    I agree with moifight club ram Kapoor deserves better roles than the saas bahu shows he was so good in hazaaron khwahishein aisi

  5. Ravi says:

    Awesome review Fatema.

    Thanks for the detail and length in which you’ve talked about t he movie — it’s been a great read.

    I’m glad to hear that the central characters, Rohan and his father Bhairav, were essayed brilliantly by the actors. Both of the characters sound very intriguing and powerful!

    I’m looking forward to watching this movie when it releases!

    God bless.

  6. […] Udaan Review – It speaks from the heart and goes right through it In Uncategorized on May 25, 2010 at 4:27 PM by Fatema Kagalwala Courtesy of Fight club […]

  7. Fatema says:

    Thanks Ravi. The poetry is another treat that I missed out on mentioning. Very well-penned. Deep yet not mysterious. Captures the mindset of a precocious teenager so well. Beautiful in its lyricism but not profound in its understanding. Its very difficult to write like that.

  8. […] Udaan Review – It speaks from the heart and goes right through it says Fatema Kagalwala […]

  9. […] looks a lot like Imran Khan and acts million times better than him. For our review of Udaan click here, for Vikramaditya Motwane & Anurag Kashyap’s video interviews here, for earlier […]

  10. cheshta says:

    hows ronit’s performance….??????????

  11. Fatema says:

    Controlled and apt. Very well-done.

  12. Pankit says:

    Anurag Kashyap have a habit of making good films. I am his fan since i watched movie “Black Friday” Fantastic. I think this one too will make an impact.

  13. chinmay says:

    since “Black Friday” I am A.K.’s(!) fan. Hope this film doesn’t get banned due to some silly censorship reasons (like Paanch). By the way, if it is going to release in India, then can you tell me at which date? Till then cheers for AK’s Machine gun (i.e Anurag Kashyap’s Motwane!) and many many many thnaks for the review of “Udaan”

  14. India’s biggest problem -> Wasting the most productive part of a student’s life into things he never knew, wanted or loved.What a shame we revel in.

    Find something to die for and then live for it.

  15. […] J. Grin (we just can’t get enough of it). Also, releasing this friday is Udaan. And click here to read our review of […]

  16. Bollyfan says:

    Fatema, moifightclub : I’m jealous of you all…you got to see it earlier, thus savouring it much longer than me. You guys owe me a beer each!

  17. Utkal Mohanty says:

    A very well-written review. The piece in today’s Sunday’s Express has brought out some more sharp insights.

  18. Fatema says:

    Thanks Utkal.

  19. kennydb says:

    @ MFC
    Regarding Ram Kapoor. Sahi! I have a co-fan. His three scenes were the best thing about Karthik Calling Karthik. Even in Udaan, he’s so bloody natural. Effortless. You’d love to have a chacha like him. He really deserves better than the saas bahu shit

  20. moifightclub says:

    @kenny – You’d love to have a chacha like him <—- was thinking the same when i saw it 2nd time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.